Article by Maryvel De Castro Valdes in Today’s Daily Business Review: “Ruling Proves Community Associations Need to Revise Own Governing Documents”

Siegfried Rivera
June 24, 2020


An article authored by firm shareholder Maryvel De Castro Valdes is featured as the “Board of Contributors” guest commentary column in today’s edition of the Daily Business Review, South Florida’s exclusive business daily and official court newspaper.  The article, which is titled “Ruling Proves Community Associations Need to Revise Own Governing Documents,” focuses on a recent ruling by Florida’s Third District Court of Appeal that added to the growing string of decisions in recent years illustrating how an old and outdated provision in HOA and condominium association declarations is preventing some communities from collecting what they would be owed under the current state law from purchasers in foreclosure actions.  Her article reads:

. . . The ruling came in the case of Old Cutler Lakes by the Bay Community Association v. SRP SUB, LLC. The LLC took title to a unit within the community via a mortgage foreclosure auction and subsequently filed an action for declaratory relief seeking to determine its liability for the association assessments that accrued prior to acquiring title.

While Florida law holds that a parcel owner is jointly and severally liable with the previous owner for all unpaid assessments that came due up to the time of transfer of title, including by purchase at a foreclosure sale, the LLC was apparently well aware that the association’s declaration contained a provision that essentially extinguished its liability for the past-due assessments owed by the previous owner.

Old Cutler Lakes’ declaration reads:

“The sale or transfer of any Lot pursuant to the foreclosure or any proceeding in lieu thereof of a first mortgage meeting the above qualifications, shall extinguish the lien of such assessments as to payments which became due prior to such sale or transfer.”

The LLC’s arguments did not end there. It also relied on the Third DCA’s 2017 opinion in Beacon Hill Homeowners Association v. Colfin Ah-Florida 7, which addressed these same declaration provisions and cited a Fourth DCA ruling from 2015.

In the May ruling, the Third DCA panel concluded that the trial court’s amended final judgment provided a thorough and well-reasoned analysis of the relevant provisions of the community’s declaration and the application of the appellate court’s 2017 decision in Beacon Hill. It found no error in the lower court’s interpretation of the relevant provisions and affirmed the amended final judgment concluding the LLC is not liable for any of the past-due assessments, attorney’s fees and/or costs that accrued prior to its acquiring title.

This ruling adds to the growing consensus among Florida’s district courts of appeal that community associations’ existing governing documents override Florida law placing liability on the new owner for the previous owner’s past-due assessments.

While many community association governing documents mirror the language in the current Florida Condominium Act and Homeowner Association Act, there are numerous older communities with governing documents that extinguish a successor’s liability for the previous owner’s assessments. Those communities should consider amending their governing documents to allow them to collect from the eventual buyers of units at mortgage foreclosure sales and avoid complete write-offs of past assessments.

It is important to note that association governing documents can vary greatly, and the amendment procedure/mechanism will differ by community. Associations and their boards of directors should review their governing documents with the help of highly qualified condo and HOA attorneys to identify these outdated provisions. If an amendment is in order, the board and/or membership must vote to approve the amendment language and, if approved, record the amendment in the public records. Keep in mind that an amendment will only take effect after it is properly recorded in the public records and may not apply retroactively. . .

Our firm salutes Maryvel for sharing her insights into the takeaways from this recent appellate decision with the readers of the Daily Business ReviewClick here to read the complete article in the newspaper’s website (registration required).