Firm’s Latest Miami Herald Column by Evonne Andris: “Response to Negative TV News Report by HOA Shows How It’s Done”

Siegfried Rivera
November 20, 2022


The firm’s latest Miami Herald “Real Estate Counselor” column is authored by partner Evonne Andris and appears in today’s edition of the newspaper.  The article, which is titled “Response to Negative TV News Report by HOA Shows How It’s Done,” focuses on a recent case from San Antonio, Texas, involving a homeowner’s car that was wrongfully towed by her HOA.  As often happens in such instances of community association missteps, the homeowner responded by reporting the incident to her favorite local TV news station.  Evonne’s article reads:

. . . “We looked into the claim,” begins the story from KENS 5, the city’s CBS affiliate. Jennifer Holmquist tells the station her son’s car was suddenly gone from their driveway, and they were about to report it stolen when they learned it had been towed by the Mountain Lodge Homeowner’s Association with no advance warning.

“Nothing on the door, no phone call, no email,” she complains to the reporter. She also bemoans that she was told by the towing company it would cost $300 to get the car back.

In similar situations of community association disputes across the country, what typically follows is an account of how the reporter attempted to get a response from the association, but none was forthcoming. In some cases, the journalists receive a written response from the association’s attorney that defends its actions and holds firm that they were in accordance with the community’s policies and regulations.

However, when the acts taken by an association are in error, simple no comment responses or those focusing on community policies and regulations may not be the best position to take. Such cases highlight the importance of a well thought out response. In this situation, it was verified that the removal of the vehicle on the community’s behalf was the result of a miscommunication with the HOA’s towing company, so the association and its board of directors had a decision to make.

To their credit, the HOA’s directors and their legal counsel moved quickly to take the best possible approach, and it is very much reflected in the station’s report.

“The towing is the result of miscommunication to the individual that tagged the vehicle and he was unaware of the moratorium on enforcement. Once the board was notified the car had been mistakenly towed, the board ordered its return at no expense to the owner or the association,” reads its written statement from its attorney provided to the reporter.

In fact, the full statement goes on to include some background and context, and it states the association was also willing to pay for repairs related to the towed vehicle’s brake maintenance light having turned on. It reads:

“The present situation dates back to February 2020. Since that date, there have been numerous courtesy and violation letters (by first class and certified mail) sent to Mr. and Mrs. Holmquist advising of the ongoing violations and of the necessity to make alternative parking arrangements or make modifications to their property to permit off-street parking for all their vehicles as do other residents in Mountain Lodge. . .

“The vehicle was tagged on Sunday and advised the vehicle would be towed if not moved. As of Monday, the vehicle was not moved, remained blocking the sidewalk and the tag was visibly removed. There was no attempt by Mr. and Mrs. Holmquist to contact the Association about the mistake resulting in the vehicle being towed.”

The statement, which is included in its entirety together with the link to the HOA’s parking/towing policy in the station’s website, concludes:

“Once the Board was notified the car had been mistakenly towed, the Board ordered its return at no expense to the owner or the Association. Also, as a result of the braking system maintenance light being on, the Association has offered to tow the vehicle to a Toyota dealership of the owner’s choice and any needed repairs to the system will be covered by the Association. The Board sincerely regrets this matter has escalated to the level it has and hopefully the problem can be resolved with the expansion of the owner’s driveway.”

The end result is a fairly humdrum story about a local HOA that made an honest mistake, but its board of directors quickly owned up to it and made it right. It could have easily been an extremely negative report about an association that frivolously tows its homeowners’ vehicles with no prior warning. However, the board and attorney’s proactive approach to quickly address and correct the error, and provide the reporter with a written statement completely turns it around into a positive report for the community. . .

Evonne concludes her article by noting that given the expanded use of video and teleconferences, it has become fairly simple for boards of directors and their attorneys to schedule brief meetings to address any errors in association operations and/or responses to concerning media inquiries that may arise.  She writes that by responding to such inquiries as effectively and expeditiously as possible, associations and their attorneys can help to avoid potentially damaging and one-sided media coverage.

Our firm salutes Evonne for sharing her insights into this case and its takeaways for associations responding to potentially negative media coverage with the readers of the Miami HeraldClick here to read the complete article in the newspaper’s website.